I don't just mean this because the subjects here were bleak or depressing, although they were--a divorced man struggling to define love in a world on the brink of war; two musicians forced to accept their failure to achieve fame (or money); the ghost of an old friend making an appearance to say goodbye. But at some level, it felt as though the stories got lost on their way to deliver a message; the cleverness of the situations got in the way of relaying anything but disappointment and frustration. But then, each of the characters here are disappointed, frustrated, or some lethal combination of the two--so perhaps that was the intent, as Moore drives readers to accept the certainty of our own mortality, the bleakness of our inner selves, the sadness of progress.
Ultimately, I appreciated a glimpse into Moore's skill with language, which is awe-inspiring, to say the least, and though I found the collection a bit uneven, there were parts of it that really hit it home. While this may not have been the best entry point into Moore's work, I'm still planning to visit her previous writing, and hoping for the best.
Has anyone else read this one? How does it compare to Birds of America or her novel, The Gate at the Stairs?
---
Thoughts from other bookworms:
The New York Times (1st review - quite the disappointment) and (2nd review - he liked it!)
The Boston Globe
Publisher's Weekly
---
Thank you to the publisher for providing an e-galley of this title for review.
Bark: Stories | Lorrie Moore | Knopf | February 2014 | Hardcover | 208 pages
I've been bummed to see that people are not too thrilled with this (both both veterans and newbies alike). I've only read Anagrams, which was one of her novels, but absolutely adored it. I hope you end up giving her other writing a shot!
ReplyDeleteI didn't like this book much at all, but I in no way feel like that will prevent me from reading more of Moore's work. So it wasn't all bad, I guess.
DeleteOK, I can weigh in on this! I read Gate and really did not like it so was nervous about Bark. I liked Bark alot- the stories were quirky and to me right on the money regarding the screwiness of human relationships. Not all were great but enough that I'm now back to thinking I want to read more from Lorrie Moore. My two cents.
ReplyDeleteInteresting. I've seen a total mixed bag of reviews of this one, ranging from calling it the worst of Moore's writing to delivering exactly what we've come to expect from Moore in terms of humor, wit, and crisp language. It just didn't find its mark with me, I guess!
DeleteHmmm never read anything by Moore (yet). Perhaps (based on your review and other comments) I should start with some of her other work!
ReplyDeleteThis one has gotten very, VERY mixed reviews, so maybe it is the right place for some people... just wasn't for me.
DeleteSorry to hear this fell a little flat. I haven't read anything by Moore ywr, but I guess it's good to know that I shouldn't start with this book!
ReplyDeleteFlat is actually the perfect description. Maybe it was too-high expectations? Whatever the case, it just didn't work for me.
DeletePlease, please! Read BIRDS OF AMERICA! Also a short story collection, brilliant, classic, never ever flat!
ReplyDelete